The September meeting of the Arizona Alternative Business Structures (ABS) Committee was a busy session, covering five initial license applications and five renewal applications, along with compliance updates and a discussion of upcoming program changes.
- Initial Licenses: Of the five applications, three were approved (two with some recusals), two were deferred for additional information and fact finding.
- Renewals: Of the five renewals, two were approved, two were deferred, and one was denied due to ongoing misconduct and lack of cooperation.
The committee also reviewed compliance lawyer changes, inactive status requests, and discussed proposed rule and process changes aimed at simplifying applications and strengthening oversight.
Initial Licenses
Overview
Five new ABS applicants were considered.
- Approved: Hunterbrook Law, Litix Legal, and Ellis Legal
- Deferred: Law Max Group and Ask A Pro Law
- Denied: None
Approved
- Hunterbrook Law, LLC
Plaintiff firm connected to investigative journalism work.
After extensive discussion about the firm’s out-of-state roots and its unique integration of investigative journalism with legal services, the committee voted to approve the license.- Discussion Highlights:
- Committee Member Hay expressed concern that the ABS framework was intended to benefit Arizona-based firms and questioned whether this out-of-state firm aligned with that purpose.
- Committee Member German saw potential for the model to grow within Arizona, provided the law firm develops a local presence.
- Chair Foster noted doubts about how the firm would operate but stated there was no rule-based reason to deny the application.
- Vote: 1 no (Committee Member Hay), 1 recusal (Committee Member Shely), all others in favor.
- Discussion Highlights:
- Litix Legal, LLC
Flat-fee family law and plaintiff work.
The committee appreciated the focus on access to justice through flat fees.- Discussion Highlights:
- Committee Member Hay asked about timekeeping practices under a flat-fee model.
- Committee Member Kvesic questioned the firm’s purpose in using the ABS structure, which was to offer equity to a non-lawyer partner.
- Chair Foster reminded applicants not to have a website live before licensure.
- Vote: Unanimous approval.
- Discussion Highlights:
- Ellis Legal, LLC
Immigration law practice focused on accessibility and transparency.
Despite questions about out-of-state practice, the committee was satisfied with the compliance plan and guarantees around client transparency.- Vote: Unanimous approval, with Committee Members Kvesic and German recused.
Deferred
- Law Max Group, LLC
The application lacked additional information that had been requested. Deferred again. - Ask A Pro Law
Concerns were raised about whether the firm would function as a true law firm or simply a referral service.- Committee Member Shely asked for more clarity on the firm’s purpose under the ABS rules.
- Committee Member Barnes raised concerns about the public being misled by a live website.
- Vote: Motion to defer approved, with Committee Member German opposed.
License Renewals
Overview
Five renewal applications were reviewed.
- Approved: Ryan Legal Services and Fidelity Legal
- Deferred: Wilkie Puchi and Novus Lex
- Denied: Scout Law Group
Approved
- Ryan Legal Services, PLLC
Tax solution firm serving both businesses and individuals.- Vote: Unanimous approval for a two-year renewal.
- Fidelity Legal, LLC
Addressed compliance updates and provided operational details.- Vote: Unanimous approval.
Deferred
- Wilkie Puchi, LLP
Employment law firm.- Deferred because no representatives attended the meeting.
- Novus Lex, LLC
Litigation support firm operating with Arizona co-counsel.- Deferred to review original application for alignment with current operations.
Denied
- Scout Law Group, LLC
Due to an alleged history of dishonesty, failure to respond to committee requests, and ongoing misconduct, the committee denied renewal.- Motion: Made by Committee Member Hay, seconded by Committee Member Shely.
- Vote: Unanimous among eligible members.
Compliance and Licensee Updates
Several compliance lawyer and authorized person changes were addressed:
- Approved Changes:
- Rocket Legal: New designated principal and authorized person.
- United Alliance Law: Compliance lawyer change approved.
- The Meadow Law Firm: Compliance lawyer change approved.
- Copper Wren Law: Multiple compliance lawyer changes approved.
- Accident Recovery Law Firm: Compliance lawyer change approved.
- Deferred:
- Mayfair Legal: Compliance lawyer change deferred for further review.
- Inactive Status:
- Trademarkia Venture Partners: Approved for inactive status.
Future Program Changes
At the close of the meeting, the committee discussed potential changes to the ABS program to simplify the application process and strengthen oversight.
Application Streamlining
- Combine separate applications for authorized persons and compliance lawyers into one main application.
- Clarify requirements in these sections:
- Section 3: Clearly list practice areas.
- Section 4: Identify regulatory objectives and explain how they’ll be met.
- Section 5: Detail governance structure and decision-making authority.
- Section 8: Remove duplicate ownership questions.
Proposed Rule Changes
- Raise ownership threshold for reporting from 10% to 25%.
- Expand definition of decision-making authority to include those who can legally bind or substantially control an ABS.
- Require an active Arizona-licensed lawyer in good standing at all times.
- Add “protection of the public” as a stated purpose of the ABS program.
- Broaden equity ownership rules to include related persons of law firms, beyond non-lawyer heirs.
These changes are expected to move to the Arizona Judicial Council in October, with implementation planned by December.
Looking Ahead
The next ABS Committee meeting is scheduled for October 14, 2025. It will likely address deferred applications, ongoing compliance updates, and continued work on these rule changes.
*Disclaimer*
The information in this post is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, details may change and readers should verify information with the official Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action.







