Tag

MSO

Arizona Supreme Court Committee on Alternative Business Structures. Conference Room 109 and Zoom. 9:00 a.m. The agenda included ten initial applications, four renewals, and four licensee updates.

The opinions expressed here are those of Arizona ABS Law and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Once published, official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website.

INITIAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Vanteo Law, LLC
A multidisciplinary immigration practice that will pair two full-time immigration attorneys with a workforce mobility consulting arm. That arm already places international candidates with employers. The firm will offer Arizona residents a 20% discount. Approved unanimously.

Stone & Arrow Law Firm, LLC
Back for a second look. The Committee denied Stone & Arrow in July. The firm then requested a disciplinary hearing and tried to use it to amend its application. The Committee ruled that a disciplinary hearing isn’t for that and sent the matter back for a fresh vote. The result didn’t change: denied unanimously.

OpenLaw Legal Services, LLC
A technology-driven firm that will match Arizona residents with legal counsel and use proprietary AI tools for the administrative work. The Committee wanted to know whether the compliance attorney holds in-house counsel status or a full Arizona license. Division staff got the attorney on the call during the meeting. The Committee deferred until the attorney’s full bar admission comes through.

OneDigital Legal Services, LLC
Estate planning, wealth transfer, and transactional work under a parent company’s larger umbrella. The Committee pressed on whether the structure creates a referral incentive that could compromise the legal side’s independence. OneDigital said no financial incentive will run between the entities, and that answer satisfied the Committee. Approved unanimously.

Aureum Legal, LLC
Corporate and transactional services for family office clients. The firm will move from hourly billing to a flat monthly rate. The founder wants the ABS so he can bring on business leaders to broaden the firm’s strategic bench. Approved unanimously.

Booth Udall, PLC
Intellectual property work, mostly patents and trademarks, for technology clients. The compliance attorney couldn’t attend and submitted an affidavit covering their background instead. The firm will also use the ABS structure to hire attorneys straight out of law school. Approved unanimously.

Gateway Law, LLC
A boutique personal injury firm that will pair a long-time litigator with a business partner to compete with the larger PI shops in the state. The Committee stated the application was strong and had few questions. Approved unanimously.

Jackson Tyler, PLLC
Jackson Tyler asked for a deferral to a later date. The Committee granted it unanimously.

TFW Law, PLLC
Domestic and international asset protection and estate planning. For the second meeting in a row, no one appeared for the applicant, and parts of the file are still incomplete. The Committee asked Division staff to confirm TFW still intends to pursue the license before the application comes back.

OGC Solutions, LLC
An outside general counsel model built on fixed monthly fees. The firm plans to add HR and financial support services later. The Committee asked how the firm will structure attorney roles across multiple clients, and how each attorney’s employment status will interact with their individual license. Approved unanimously.

RENEWAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

My Visa Source Legal Corp
Immigration law, marketed only in Arizona. The firm has no paying clients yet and has been building toward launch with pro bono consultations. Approved unanimously.

Charter Law Group
In June, the State Corporation Commission flagged a conflict-of-interest concern involving the firm’s majority owner. The concern relates to that owner’s personal investments at an outside investment firm. The Commission found the conduct negligent but not intentional. Charter’s spokesperson told the Committee the owner doesn’t practice at the firm, but said they hadn’t had time to prepare a full response. The Committee unanimously postponed the renewal to next month.

Heritage Family Offices, LLC
The company asked for a deferral to next month.

1787 Legal Group, LLC
No one appeared for the firm, so the Committee moved the decision to next month’s agenda.

LICENSEE UPDATES

United Alliance Law, PLLC
Surrendering its license. The owners will shift their focus elsewhere, partly because other states, California among them, are tightening restrictions on ABS entities. Approved unanimously.

Jacoby & Meyers
Formerly National Mass Tort & Class Action Law Firm. Requesting inactive status. Turnover in leadership and staffing has kept the firm from launching, and it has no clients or activity yet. A second renewal comes due in November. The firm wants to regroup and reassess its authorized personnel before a real launch, and still plans to file for renewal next month. Approved unanimously.

Mariner Law Firm, LLC
Surrendering its license. The entity never moved forward with legal services and doesn’t expect to. Approved unanimously.

Sterling Shield Legal, LLC
Surrendering its license. No one from the company attended. Approved unanimously.

ADMINISTRATIVE NOTES

Forty-three applications are pending, including this meeting’s deferrals. The Division is moving to a new technology vendor. There’s unfortunately no timeline yet for the switch. The Committee also asked that its notes flag any applicant who has been deferred before, so the history travels with the file.

Comments on proposed changes to ACJA § 7-209 go to the Access to Justice Commission meeting in Flagstaff on October 27. The proposal would ease the external audit requirement for some of the pending changes. It also includes a provision barring committee members from appearing before the Committee, and a separate one letting them appear as compliance attorneys.

The Committee also discussed setting up working groups for compliance audits, data gathering, application review, and training for nonlawyer applicants and others new to the ABS system.

Next ABS Committee meeting: November 10, 2026.


The information in this post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Details may change. Verify information with the Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action. The opinions expressed are those of Arizona ABS Law and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website once published.

NALFA is becoming the Center for Innovative Legal Services, and I’m proud to be one of the founders.

A quick note first. Most of what I publish on substack sticks to the facts: Committee recaps, rule changes, bill breakdowns. This post is my opinion. These views are mine alone. They don’t represent the Arizona Supreme Court, its Committee on Alternative Business Structures, CILS, NALFA, or any other organization I’m part of.

The News

This past weekend was the annual National ABS Law Firm Association (NALFA) conference. NALFA saved its biggest news for last. On Saturday, September 26, as the final item of the conference in Scottsdale, Lucian Pera and interim NALFA president Nic Edgson announced that NALFA is becoming the Center for Innovative Legal Services, or CILS.

NALFA started as a trade association for ABS law firms, and it did lots of that job well. It offered CLE, compliance resources, networking, and an annual ABS conference. CILS will keep all of that. It will also add independent research, education, and a place for people who rarely talk to each other to sit down together.

Current NALFA members will become CILS members automatically. New leadership and board seats are on the way, and more details will go up at innovativelegal.org.

Why Now

I think the practice of law has hit a tipping point, and the evidence is out in the open.

On one side, the momentum is real. At its July meeting, Arizona’s ABS Committee reported 52 pending applications. MSOs are forming across the country. New firms are building on AI from their first day of operation.

On the other side, the pushback has turned into law. California passed AB 931, which bars California lawyers from sharing fees with ABS firms. Colorado passed HB26-1421, and Illinois passed its own legislation. Both of those states banned ABSs and tightened the rules on MSOs.

Three states have already shut the door, and others are watching to see who follows. Legislatures and bar committees are deciding these fights right now, and too often they hear only one side.

Why a Bigger Tent?

A trade association for ABS firms speaks for ABS firms. That’s useful, but it has limits. When a legislator hears from an industry group, they hear a business protecting its own interests, and they weigh what it says with that in mind.

California, Colorado, and Illinois went after our models one bill at a time. Our opponents aren’t sorting us into separate camps, so I don’t think we should sort ourselves. If ABS firms, MSOs, legal tech companies, and AI-native firms each fight alone, we’ll keep losing ground one state at a time.

CILS will open the door to all of them. That includes ABS law firms, MSOs, MSO-enabled firms, AI-native firms, compliance and ethics lawyers, investors, investment bankers, academics, consultants, and legal tech companies. As a nonpartisan center, it will also welcome regulators, policymakers, and the public. A trade group can’t credibly put those people in a room together. A center can.

Here is the mission:

“The Center for Innovative Legal Services (CILS) advances the future of legal services through independent research, education, collaboration, and informed dialogue. It brings together diverse perspectives to examine emerging models, technologies, business structures, and regulatory frameworks; promotes sound practices and thoughtful innovation; and serves as a trusted, nonpartisan resource for the legal profession, policymakers, regulators, and the public.”

What CILS Will Do

CILS will focus on five things:

  1. Regulatory monitoring and engagement. CILS will track legislative and regulatory activity affecting ABS and MSO models as it happens, and it will talk directly with legislators, regulators, and bar authorities about pending changes.
  2. Research and publications. CILS will partner with academic institutions to study how reforms and new delivery models affect the public, clients, and lawyers.
  3. Best practices and compliance. CILS will publish guidance on forming and running ABS firms and MSO-enabled firms across multiple jurisdictions.
  4. Education. CILS will host an annual national summit and hold regular meetings on the issues that come up in between.
  5. Public messaging. CILS will build coalitions and help shape how the public understands these changes.

Each of these matters to me, because each one fills a gap I’ve run into myself. I’ve watched bills move through legislatures before almost anyone in our world knew they existed. I’ve heard reform attacked with assumptions and not much data. I’ve fielded calls from founders trying to piece together compliance rules across three or four states. The best conversations I’ve had about ABS or MSO reform happened when a skeptic sat across from someone running a licensed firm, and both walked away knowing more than when they came in. CILS will take on each of those problems and bring people into the room on purpose.

Proud to Be Part of This

I’m honored to be part of the founding group as an advisor. It includes Don Bivens and Lucian Pera, two lawyers who have spent decades shaping how our profession thinks about ethics and regulation. Having them at the table tells regulators and skeptics that CILS will take the hard questions seriously.

The rest of the group spans BigLaw ethics partners, researchers at universities, ABS founders, venture investors, AI companies, and plaintiff firms. That mix is the point. Nobody in the group sees the whole picture alone, and together we come a lot closer.

How to Get Involved

  • Stay with us. If you’re a NALFA member, your membership carries over.
  • Help us recruit. If you know someone who belongs in this tent, send them our way. We’re looking for MSOs, ABS firms, AI native founders, compliance lawyers, investors, academics, and legal tech builders.
  • Volunteer. If you want to help steer the organization, raise your hand. We need people who have done this work and know where the problems are.
  • Watch the website. Keep an eye on innovativelegal.org. More details are coming soon.

I’ve spent so much energy arguing that law practice reform is both a market opportunity and an access-to-justice issue. I still believe that. CILS is the best chance I’ve seen to make that case to everyone who needs to hear it, all at once.

The views in this post are personal and do not represent the position of the Committee on Alternative Business Structures, the Arizona Supreme Court, the Center for Innovative Legal Services, or any organization with which the author is affiliated.

Last week, Bloomberg Law reached out to me to talk about where legal services investment is heading, and specifically why private equity has cooled on Arizona’s ABS program. Short version: since August 2025, only 5 of 42 ABS applications have involved outside financing. Investors have moved to Management Services Organizations. Here’s why that’s not the whole story.

California restricted ABS fee-sharing in 2025. Illinois and Colorado followed. When enough capital flows through a legal services structure with minimal oversight, legislatures take notice. Sometimes they move to ban what they find.

Arizona ABS firms operate under rules the Arizona Supreme Court created and continues to enforce. 171 are licensed and operating today. The Committee on Alternative Business Structures reviews their ownership arrangements. The state knows what’s inside every licensed firm.

Many MSOs are run carefully by people who take compliance seriously. The structure itself isn’t the problem. The problem is that without formal oversight, bad actors can operate in the same space. It doesn’t take many high-profile failures to prompt a Colorado or Illinois-style crackdown.

If you’re building a legal services company meant to run for a decade or more, that’s worth factoring in before you commit to a structure.

Read the full Bloomberg Law piece here: Investors Chase Law Firm Back Offices as Arizona Interest Cools

The ABS world is almost always described from the attorney’s chair. Garrett Bell sits somewhere else.

My brother started working for me in January, and now, eight months in, I’ve decided to put him in the hot seat. For this edition of “5 Questions With…” I wanted to get the perspective of the person who bears the brunt of the administrative burden in our ABS process. What trends does he see in effective applications? What surprises has he encountered? And most importantly, am I a good boss? 

  1. Without any legal training going in, how did you get up to speed on what ABS actually is and why it matters — and what resources or experiences were most useful?

The most brown-nosed answer I could give, but the truth is simple: Taylor.

ABS compliance law is new enough that most people don’t fully understand what it is, what it requires, or what the process actually looks like. I came in with no legal background, so I was in good company in my ignorance. The bulk of my onboarding was devoted to conversations about ABS law: what it is, why Arizona is exploring it, and who would actually be interested in this niche field. Once I had those answers, the how became much easier to digest.

Anyone who has worked with Taylor knows he can explain complex regulatory concepts without talking over your head. It’s just how he communicates. He walks clients through the application and compliance process all the time, and I was a real-life beneficiary of that knowledge. Once I had the foundation, the next teacher was the process itself. The ABS application is still in its infancy and keeps changing. What was required in February isn’t what’s required today. Tracking the changes provides clarity on what is most important for an effective application and well run firm, versus what is an administrative burden.

The third piece was observing the monthly Committee Meetings. Nothing prepares you better than watching the sausage get made.

2. What do ABS hopefuls seem to underestimate when they first come to you?

The compliance attorney. Full stop.

Anyone who has come to us has likely done at least some research on ABS law, hopefully enough to identify that they’re going to need a compliance attorney. I’ll go out on a limb and suggest that most of them, at least in early conversations, either underestimate or, worse, undervalue how important this person actually is.

I have watched Committee Hearings where a company is sailing through, and then the qualifications of the proposed compliance attorney come into question and the boat instantly sinks. I might be projecting, but I fear business owners at times see the word “compliance” and think of that person as a glorified HR representative, not an essential member of the business with high-level access and considerable influence.

No company can apply for an ABS license without a highly qualified compliance attorney. And an important note: they don’t grow on trees.

3. Taylor both sits on the ABS Committee and at times supports clients going through it. What’s it like watching someone navigate those two roles from the inside?

Here’s the thing: I know what a good application looks like. I have observed every Committee Hearing and watched well-prepared applicants stand before the committee and blow them away with their thoroughness. I also know what a lacking application looks like. I have watched prospective business owners stand up and, within ten seconds, known they would not be recommended for approval.

An actor is served by sitting in on auditions, observing what gets said when the person auditioning leaves the room. I would advise anyone seeking an ABS license to do just that.

The committee holds applicants to high standards, and for good reason. Arizona needs access to justice, but it needs qualified, quality access. That Taylor sits on a committee that upholds those standards means he brings the same expectations to his clients. If we are approached by a prospective client and suspect they aren’t right for an Arizona ABS, then they aren’t the right client for us. Applications are approved by the Supreme Court because they represent strong, reliable candidates. Those are the people we want to see bringing access to justice to Arizona.

4. AI keeps coming up in conversations about the future of legal services. From where you sit day-to-day, are you actually using any of it,  and what do you make of the broader conversation about technology and legal practice?

A couple of weeks ago I was on vacation in San Francisco. Every billboard, every bus; AI company after AI company. It felt impersonal, not human. It left me a little unnerved.

And then I came back to work and opened Claude.

I use it every day. It has changed how I work in a real way, and I say that as someone who came into this job without a legal background. When I hit a wall in my knowledge (which still happens), I have a tool that can explain things without me having to pull Taylor away from something important. Terms lawyers use without thinking twice are sometimes over my head, and now I have a resource that closes that gap quickly. It also gives me the confidence to volunteer for tasks I wouldn’t dream of raising my hand for otherwise. That’s not nothing.

On the broader debate: I think I’m in an interesting position to watch it. AI has moved faster than any legislature, and two camps have formed in law – those who embrace it fully and those who stand opposed. I can’t fault the skeptics. Distrust of technology isn’t irrational. But that means, for anyone in this field, an obligation to educate yourself, so that whatever position you land on comes from understanding, not from a gap in it.

5. Plenty of people would run the other way from working with a sibling. You signed up. What is it really like in practice, and what has it done to the relationship?

As working adults, we spend the bulk of our day interacting with coworkers. The fact that mine happens to be my brother means that instead of talking to Susan at the metaphorical watercooler about her kid’s soccer game, I get to talk to my brother about my godchild, or an upcoming trip, or my own personal hijinks. I’ve never felt closer to my brother, and I attribute it to clear communication.

Before I started working for Taylor, we formed a Brother’s Agreement. We wanted to protect our relationship above everything else, and that safety net hovers below us whenever we may need it.

That being said, he does tend to scold me when I’m logged in past the time I should be, but then I call him out for checking his email on a family vacation. It’s easy to watch someone’s back when you know they’re watching yours.

A note from me to close it out

I asked whether I’m a good boss and never got a direct answer, which tells me eight months around lawyers is starting to show…

Two things from Garrett’s answers are worth repeating. First, the compliance lawyer. I have watched that exact boat sink in the hearing room, and it is almost always because the applicant treated the role as a title to fill rather than a person who needs real authority and real qualifications. If you are building toward an ABS, that hire is not the last thing you figure out. It is close to the first.

Second, go watch a Committee meeting. They are open. Almost nobody outside the process shows up. Spend a morning watching applications get recommended and rejected in real time and you will understand the standard better than any guide I could write for you.

As for the last question, I’ll take the scolding. He’s right about the vacation emails.

Garrett handles the part of this work that clients often don’t notice despite feeeling the most, and the firm runs better because he is the one doing it. Also, he is my brother, and I got to hire him. Not a bad trade.

Want to be in the hot seat for a future edition? Reply and tell me what you’d want to be asked about!

Disclaimer: The content of this post is intended for general information only and should not be relied on as legal advice or interpreted as creating an attorney-client relationship. Although care has been taken to present accurate information, requirements and facts can change, and readers should confirm details with the Arizona Supreme Court or other applicable regulators before acting. The views expressed are solely my own and/or those of my quoted guests and do not reflect the positions of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court.

The Arizona ABS Committee met on July 14, 2026 and reviewed four initial license applications, two renewals, and five licensee updates including one voluntary surrender.

The opinions expressed here are those of Arizona ABS Law and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Once published, official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website.


PROCEDURAL UPDATE

Starting with the July 14 meeting, the Committee changed how it handles recusals. Rather than disclosing conflicts application by application, all recusals are now announced at the top of the agenda before any applications are heard. 


CALL TO THE PUBLIC

An independent Arizona attorney addressed the Committee during the call to the public. Concerns were raised about the transparency of the ABS application review process, specifically that the public has no access to a list of pending applications. Under the current process, a company’s name appears only once it is placed on the agenda. It was argued that this limits the ability of members of the public without a direct financial interest in the outcome to raise concerns before a license is granted. The matter was referred to the division for an advisory opinion.


INITIAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Four companies sought initial ABS licenses at the July 14 meeting. Three were recommended for approval and one was unanimously denied.

Innovative Legal Partners, LLC (Silverpoint Law)

Silverpoint Law provides immigration legal services to international founders and talent-based foreign companies building businesses in the United States. The firm targets companies without institutional capital and uses technology to reduce the cost and complexity of the immigration process. The Committee’s questions focused on three areas: the compliance attorney’s role, a prior account issue that surfaced in discovery (explained as an administrative oversight with no follow-up required), and finally an issue around the multi-state licensure of the compliance attorney. The application was recommended for approval with two members opposed, both citing the compliance attorney’s licensure.

Stone and Arrow Law Firm, LLC

Stone and Arrow is a personal injury firm. The Committee identified several disclosure problems in the application. These included a name discrepancy between the application and the applicant’s legal name, inconsistent information about the number of event tickets involved in a prior incident, and incomplete treatment of a charge brought by a national company. That case was described in the application as a dismissal; the Committee established during questioning that a settlement had also occurred, and that a dismissal and a settlement are not the same thing. The Committee found that the application contained material omissions, acts constituting dishonesty on financial matters, conduct reflecting incompetence, and false written or oral representations. The division had recommended an in-depth interview. The Committee unanimously denied the application.

SilverThorne Group, LLC

SilverThorne Group is a cybersecurity management company seeking an ABS license to allow legal firms to partner with cybersecurity providers in managing legal and regulatory risk. The compliance attorney was not physically present at the hearing. The Committee asked about the compliance attorney’s experience managing lawyers and law offices, and about ownership structure and hiring authority. After pausing to bring the compliance attorney into the hearing by video, the Committee received satisfactory answers on both points. Unanimously recommended for approval.

Justicia Injury Law, LLC

Justicia Injury Law provides personal injury and estate planning services focused on underserved Spanish-speaking communities across Arizona. The firm plans to hire only bilingual Arizona-licensed attorneys. The Committee asked about the scope of practice (immigration was referenced in application materials but is planned for a later phase), the firm’s business model and whether it meaningfully increases access to legal services, and whether the structure was designed primarily to facilitate pre-litigation settlements. The compliance attorney and managing attorney addressed those concerns. The application was recommended for approval with two members opposed, with the dissenting votes citing questions about whether the model increases access to legal services.


RENEWAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Two companies were up for renewal. Both were renewed.

RP Legal Group, LLC

RP Legal Group handles personal injury and mass tort matters. No company representative was present at the hearing; the firm submitted written answers to standard Committee questions in advance. Those responses addressed client volume (several dozen, with slow progressive growth), Arizona client count (eight, with Arizona growth listed as an active priority), attorney staffing (one Arizona attorney, with hiring ongoing), and the value of the ABS structure to the company’s clients. One Committee member requested a deferral on the grounds that no one was present to answer follow-up questions, including questions about the compliance attorney’s California licensure in light of current legislation. The motion to defer failed 3-4. The renewal was approved 6-1.

Tice Mendes Law, PLLC

Tice Mendes handles immigration and bankruptcy matters for low-income clients. The Committee asked about attorney headcount (two, after a recent departure), caseload (50-70 bankruptcy and medical cases, several hundred immigration cases, with 30-40 in active court proceedings), the geographic distribution of clients (bulk are Arizona), a disclosed administrative matter with the State Bar involving a trust account (described as a minor error in how a refund was processed), and the firm’s fee-sharing arrangements given California legislation restricting fee sharing between businesses. The firm addressed each question. Approved unanimously.


LICENSEE UPDATES

Aurum Law Group – Compliance Lawyer Change

Aurum Law Group requested approval to replace its compliance attorney. The incoming compliance attorney practices criminal defense. The previous compliance attorney parted ways with the company. The Committee noted the firm had previously been focused on mass torts and asked whether it had filed paperwork to reflect a change in practice area; the company confirmed it had. Approved unanimously.

Copper State Legal Services LLC – Authorized Person Change

Copper State Legal Services requested removal of Benefit Street Partners as an authorized person and substitution of Wink Legal, LLC. The change reflects a new entity formed by the same authorized person. No questions from the Committee. Approved unanimously.

Skyview Legal Group, LLC – Adding Compliance Lawyer

Skyview Legal Group sought approval of a new compliance lawyer following the departure of its previous attorney. No representative from the company was present at the hearing to answer questions. The Committee discussed what the absence of any compliance attorney means under the rules, whether the Committee should issue a suspension letter, and what a deferral would mean in practice. The company has not yet opened its doors, which limited the immediate practical impact. A letter to the company is still required for the record. The matter was deferred to a future meeting pending the compliance attorney’s appearance before the Committee.

Harmony Law, PLLC – Compliance Lawyer and Designated Principal Change

Harmony Law sought approval for two simultaneous changes: replacement of its compliance attorney, and replacement of its designated principal. The Committee’s questions revealed that the firm, which holds an ABS license for family law work, appears to be shifting toward personal injury and possibly mass torts. Additional questions arose about the compliance attorney’s primary state of residence as well as the nature of the leadership transition, whether a sale of the firm had occurred, and whether the company has enough active cases to sustain operations. The compliance attorney was not certain about the details of the ownership transition. The Committee moved to consider the two proposed changes separately, then voted unanimously to defer both to the September meeting.

Justpoint Law, LLP – Voluntary Surrender

Justpoint Law requested voluntary surrender of its ABS license. No complaints or outstanding administrative actions are pending. No questions from the Committee. Approved unanimously.


ADMINISTRATIVE NOTES

The Committee reported 52 pending applications, plus additional applications in process through the online portal. Twelve of the pending applications are currently being reviewed by third-party private investigation companies. The September docket is expected to be heavy, in part because third-party company investigators now submit their work in bulk.

The Committee is working on two application changes targeted for completion by the end of the year. The first is a revision to the compliance attorney section requiring a clearer accounting of relevant experience, potentially including a resume, tied to a corresponding update to the application’s technology platform. The second is an update to the non-lawyer applicant training primer to reflect recent changes to the code.

Rule changes currently before the judiciary are expected to reach the October agenda. The materials will need to be posted publicly before the September meeting.


The information in this post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Details may change. Verify information with the Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action. The opinions expressed are those of Arizona ABS Law and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website once published.

Most discussions about ABS and legal service delivery treat ethics as a constraint: something to satisfy at minimum, verify once, and then move past. Anudeep Sethee has had to actually build the infrastructure behind it.

As VP and Legal Practice Leader at LegalZoom and Managing Director of LZ Legal Services, she has spent years inside a public company delivering legal services to consumers who couldn’t access traditional attorneys. That experience puts her in a different position than most voices in this debate. She has watched what non-lawyer ownership looks like in practice, what AI supervision requires when it runs at scale, and where the “legal information versus legal advice” line breaks down in the real world.

She holds a JD from USC Gould School of Law. She is skeptical of ABS critics who assume ethics collapses under outside ownership and equally skeptical of technology boosters who assume AI eliminates the parts of legal service delivery that actually require judgment. Her framing for the whole thing: legal service delivery is a design problem.

I asked her five questions about ownership ethics, AI supervision, and what the profession keeps getting wrong about both.


1. There’s a familiar argument that non-lawyer ownership dilutes professional ethics. Having worked inside a public company that delivers legal services at scale, what’s your read on that concern?

Anudeep: This is probably the argument I hear the most when it comes to concerns about non-lawyer ownership, and while I understand where the concerns are coming from, I do think it is misguided.

In a traditional law firm, the ethical framework and responsibilities are largely invisible and unverifiable. In a well-structured ABS, the ethics infrastructure is explicit, visible, and deliberate rather than assumed. When you establish and build an ABS under the kind of regulatory oversight Arizona requires, you have to operationalize everything from individual and ongoing attorney training, to quality assurance, to compliance monitoring. Individual attorney ethical responsibilities apply regardless of whether the law firm they work at is owned by attorneys or non-attorneys, and in an ABS, we are layering on entity-level obligations in addition to individual attorney obligations. On top of all that, we have a compliance lawyer whose entire role exists to ensure ethical compliance.

This is not to say that an ABS is immune to ethical failures, but neither are traditional law firms. The real question isn’t “is it possible for something to go wrong in an ABS” but actually “does it go wrong more often and/or is the harm somehow worse.” We haven’t seen anything across the US to say the answer to either of those questions is yes since ABSs have been allowed, or in other countries where there have been ABSs for decades.


2. What does “understanding” what AI is doing actually look like in practice for a managing partner or GC?

Anudeep: While I don’t believe you need to understand everything about how the model works in a technical sense, you should have an operational understanding of what data is going in, where the outputs are reliable and where they aren’t, and what happens when it gets things wrong. The questions I’d ask any managing partner or GC are: what was this tool trained on? Where does it confidently produce wrong answers? Who is accountable when a bad output makes it to a client? And is your review process actual supervision or just a cursory once-over that makes you feel compliant?

The firms I’ve seen use AI well treat it the way they would a new entry-level associate who is still calibrating to expectations and output. They have high expectations, but pair that with clear parameters and real oversight. The attorneys who have gotten burned by AI are the ones that treat it as an oracle and skip the review steps.


3. LegalZoom serves a lot of pro se filers and small-business customers. As AI gets better at drafting and advising, where does the line between “legal information” and “legal advice” need to move?

Anudeep: This is a great question, and honestly, I think the line has already moved. People are making real legal decisions based on AI output right now. Whether we call that “information” or “advice” doesn’t change what’s happening, and the regulatory framework is still catching up.

The traditional distinction made sense when legal advice was delivered person-to-person and you could evaluate the attorney’s credentials, their professional accountability, and their knowledge of your specific situation. AI disrupts all three of those things. It’s not licensed, it’s not liable in the traditional sense, and it doesn’t always know what it doesn’t know about your circumstances. The part of this conversation I think we’re not being honest enough about is that the “legal information” line also functioned as a gatekeeping mechanism that kept a lot of people from getting any help at all. If you’re a tenant who can’t afford an attorney and you’re trying to understand what you need to do to dispute your lease, you may not be choosing between AI and a lawyer. You’re choosing between AI and nothing.

What I’d like to see is a framework that moves away from who or what is giving the guidance to what safeguards are in place to protect consumers. We should ask: Is there transparency that it’s AI? Is there a human attorney accessible for complex matters? Is there accountability when something goes wrong? That’s a more honest approach to where the line needs to be than clinging to a distinction that was always a bit artificial.


4. State bar AI guidance so far has been cautious to the point of being unhelpful. If you were drafting model rules for AI use in law practice, what’s the first thing you’d put in writing? What’s the first thing you’d refuse to put in writing?

Anudeep: The first thing I’d put in writing is a real supervision requirement, not “attorneys should review AI output” because that’s vague enough to mean nothing. I mean a requirement that attorneys document what AI systems they’re using, what they’re using them for, who is responsible for reviewing the output, and what the process is when something goes wrong. Treat AI delegation the way we treat any supervised work product. The supervision principle already exists in our professional responsibility framework. We just need to apply it to AI clearly, consistently, and with actual accountability attached.

The first thing I’d refuse to put in writing is a list of which AI uses are permitted or prohibited. The technology is moving too fast, and a list-based approach will be obsolete as soon as you create it. The bar associations that tried to enumerate specific use cases in 2023 were already working from an incomplete picture. By the time any rule goes through drafting, public comment, and adoption, you’ve lost another two years of relevance.

The better approach is to trust the principles we already have, like competence, supervision, confidentiality, and candor to the tribunal, and draft guidance that explains clearly how those principles apply to AI contexts. The goal shouldn’t be controlling which tools lawyers use. It should be ensuring that whatever tools they use, clients are protected and attorneys are accountable.


5. You’ve sat at the intersection of legal tech and legal regulation in a way most lawyers haven’t. What has that vantage point changed about how you think about the practice of law itself?

Anudeep: The biggest shift for me has been learning to separate what the rules of legal practice are meant to protect from the mechanisms we’ve built to do that protecting. Most of the time they’re aligned. Attorney-client privilege exists because people need to be able to speak candidly with their lawyers to get real help. Independent professional judgment exists because clients deserve advice that isn’t distorted by someone else’s financial interests. These are genuine protections and I believe in them.

But working at LegalZoom, inside both the tech platform and the licensed law firm, I’ve had to wrestle with a harder version of the question: are the rules protecting clients, or are they protecting a market structure built for a different era? The unauthorized practice of law framework, in its current form, is a good test case. The original purpose was consumer protection. Whether it actually delivers that in the modern market, or whether it primarily limits competition in ways that price most people out of getting help at all, is a real question the profession should be debating.

This is not to say that attorneys aren’t necessary or valuable. I work with AI every day, and while it is remarkable at research, issue spotting, and pattern recognition, what it doesn’t have is judgment built from experience, the ability to read a client’s real situation underneath what they’re telling you, or the professional and ethical accountability that comes with a license.

The way I think about it now is that the best version of legal service delivery is human expertise augmented by technology. Technology handles the parts that should be quicker, more affordable, and consistent; attorneys handle the parts that require context, judgment, and the kind of wisdom you only get from seeing things end-to-end. What that vantage point has changed for me, practically, is that I think about legal service delivery as a design problem first. Consumers generally want the same thing: a clear answer, at a price they can actually pay, delivered in a way that makes them feel confident. Technology has gotten very good at parts of that. The hard work is figuring out how to keep the human meaningfully in the loop while building systems that make good legal help accessible to far more people than it reaches today.

Conclusion

What Anudeep describes, at every step, is a shift from assumption to infrastructure. Ethics programs that are visible rather than implied. AI supervision that is documented rather than gestured at. Consumer protections built around actual safeguards rather than regulatory categories that predate the tools. Whether the profession gets there through ABS reform, AI governance rules, or a reexamination of what unauthorized practice of law is actually protecting, the design question is the same: what does this system need to do for clients, and what’s the most honest way to build it?

Disclaimer: The content of this post is intended for general information only and should not be relied on as legal advice or interpreted as creating an attorney-client relationship. Although care has been taken to present accurate information, requirements and facts can change, and readers should confirm details with the Arizona Supreme Court or other applicable regulators before acting. The views expressed are solely my own and/or those of my quoted guests and do not reflect the positions of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court.

The Arizona ABS Committee met on June 9, 2026 and reviewed six initial license applications, four renewals, and four licensee updates.

The opinions expressed here are my own and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Once published, official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website.


INITIAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Six companies sought initial ABS licenses this month. Four were approved, one deferred, and one drew significant scrutiny over candor in disclosure.

DMX Partners, LLC

DMX Partners provides in-house legal services to portfolio companies held within private equity funds. Currently based in the UK, the company works with investors in private equity funds and is looking to expand into the United States. The Committee questioned whether this model serves Arizonans in any meaningful way, whether Arizona attorneys would be hired, and whether the company would maintain a real presence in the state. The application passed 5-4, with the four opposing votes citing the company’s thin connection to Arizona.

The Mesothelioma Center, LLC

The company requested a deferral. No action was taken.

Casium Legal, LLC

Casium Legal handles immigration law through a proprietary technology platform designed to ease application processes for both employers and employees. The ABS structure brings legal services in-house within that platform. Approved with no opposition.

Zanes Law Injury Lawyers

Zanes Law is an existing personal injury firm using the ABS license as part of a succession plan, allowing a partner to take on majority ownership going forward. Questions came up around who would serve as legal counsel if the succession plan took effect, given the husband-and-wife structure of the company. Approved with no opposition.

Win Law Group, LLC

Win Law Group focuses on personal injury for Spanish-speaking clients, handling motor vehicle accidents and other traumatic incidents. The attorney set to lead the firm has a background in chiropractic and physical therapy that he brings to his legal practice. A misdemeanor on one applicant’s record raised questions about whether the application disclosed everything it should have. Those concerns deepened when the Committee discovered the company was already advertising legal services in Arizona on its website before receiving a license. The Committee strongly recommended to the applicant that they amend their application to include proper disclosures and the applicant requested leave to amend.

Snow, Carpio & Weekley, PLLC (dba Arizona Work Injury Firm)

This pre-existing work injury law firm is restructuring as an ABS to allow a non-lawyer to hold an ownership interest. Carpio helped build the firm from the ground up. The application materials were thorough enough that the Committee needed no discussion beyond what was submitted. Approved with no opposition.


RENEWAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Four companies were up for renewal this month. All four were approved.

Meta-Attorney PC

Meta-Attorney was originally designed to support clients within the metaverse. After shifts in that market, the company pivoted and has since expanded toward national reach through AI-based legal research. Approved with no opposition.

Reliant Law Group, PLLC

Reliant serves 1,800 Arizona clients and maintains a healthy staff of Arizona-based attorneys. Approved with no opposition.

ABPV, LLC

ABPV is not yet operating but has acquired office space and is building out its technology stack to serve small businesses and entrepreneurs. The company is currently interviewing attorneys and law offices in preparation for launch. Approved with no opposition.

JusticeDirect Law Firm LLC

JusticeDirect targets low- and middle-income clients, with a particular focus on landlord-tenant matters and small claims court. The firm has four Arizona attorneys and handled 54 cases before pausing to recalibrate after demand outpaced capacity. Approved with no opposition.


LICENSEE UPDATES

National Justice Partners, LLC

National Justice Partners sought approval to change its compliance attorney. The Committee raised concerns about the incoming attorney’s non-Arizona residency, but was satisfied with the responses. Approved with no opposition.

Ask a Pro Law, LLC

Ask a Pro Law requested a compliance attorney change. Questions arose about the new Compliance attorney’s qualifications, given that his background is in criminal law and the firm handles family law matters. The Committee found the application insufficient and gave permission for the applicant to resubmit.

Copper Wren Law, LLC

Copper Wren Law requested a compliance attorney change. Approved with no opposition.

Sunridge Law Group, LLC

Sunridge Law Group requested a name change to True North Justice, LLC.


Administrative Notes

The Committee reported 68 pending applications and 11 pending renewals. Going forward, quicker agenda items will move to the front of the agenda, written summaries will no longer be read aloud during meetings, and committee members will be required to submit recusal forms.


The information in this post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Details may change. Verify information with the Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action. The opinions expressed are my own and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website once published.

Access to legal services in Arizona is changing. We should want it to.

Arizona ranks 49th nationally for attorney access. The National Center for Access to Justice places the state near the bottom on self-representation policies. Rule 31 is a direct response to that gap.

Six years in, opinions remain split. Those defending the status quo frame the ABS structure as a threat to lawyer independence. Those pushing for change argue the profession was already failing the people it’s supposed to serve. For this installment of 5 Questions With…, we set that debate aside and focus on the ethics.

Trisha M. Rich practices legal ethics and professional responsibility, with work spanning litigation, MSO structuring, ABS compliance, and outside general counsel for law firms. She is a past president of the Association of Professional Responsibility Lawyers and takes over as president of the Chicago Bar Association this month.

I asked her five questions about outside investment, structuring, and where the legal market is headed.


1. As someone who describes yourself as “ethics first,” what do you say to skeptics in the legal profession who see outside investment as a threat to lawyer independence?

Trisha: I understand the concern because lawyer independence is foundational to everything we do. Clients trust lawyers because they believe lawyers put client interests and professional obligations first, ahead of outside economic pressures.

What I tell skeptics, though, is that outside investment isn’t a unique threat. Lawyers operate under economic pressures every day. Law firms have partners, compensation systems, lenders, landlords, and clients. Economic incentives always exist. The real question is whether the structure has sufficient safeguards to protect lawyer independence in the exercise of professional judgment. We have Rules and obligations for exactly that: conflicts, independence, and more. Either lawyers follow them because they’re obligated to, or they won’t. The mere presence of outside investment in the law (which has existed for decades) won’t change that.

As a legal ethics lawyer, I start with these principles every time. If a structure can’t preserve lawyer independence, confidentiality, loyalty, and compliance with the Rules of Professional Conduct, I’m not interested, and we won’t recommend or structure it. But if those values can be protected, and in many instances they can be, then we should evaluate these models based on evidence rather than assumptions. Too often, discussions about legal innovation get framed as being either “for” or “against” change. My view is simpler: ethics first. Always.

A lot of the current rhetoric in this field is misinformed, misguided, or worse, intentionally designed to spread misinformation to discourage competition under the guise of protecting clients. What I do is work with lawyers, law firms, and investors to ensure that lawyers and law firms remain independent and free from outside influence. That is my charge as an ethics lawyer.


2. When a law firm or entrepreneur comes to you and asks, “Should we go the Arizona ABS route or structure as an MSO in our home state?” what are the key factors that drive your strategy?

Trisha: The first thing I tell clients is that this isn’t primarily a legal question. It’s a business question.

Before we discuss Arizona versus an MSO structure, I want to understand what they’re actually trying to accomplish. Are they seeking outside capital? Trying to scale nationally? Is technology a core part of the business model? Are they acquiring firms, building a referral platform, expanding consumer access? Do they have an actual connection or nexus to Arizona? Once we understand the objectives, we can evaluate which structure best aligns with those goals while remaining compliant with the applicable ethical rules. In some situations, an Arizona ABS is the right answer. In most others, an MSO structure is more practical, more scalable, or more consistent with the client’s business strategy.

The biggest mistake people make is treating Arizona ABS and MSO structures as competing products. They solve different problems.


3. For a lawyer or entrepreneur just starting to explore whether an Arizona ABS is right for them, what’s the very first conversation they should be having, and with whom?

Trisha: With themselves and their existing business partners. That may sound flippant, but I mean it.

Before talking to lawyers, ethicists, consultants, or investors, they need to answer a simple question: why are they considering this structure in the first place? What problem are they trying to solve? Do they need extra capital? If yes, what’s the right way to access it, and what would they do with it?

We regularly meet people who have become fascinated by the mechanics of ABSs, MSOs, ownership structures, or regulatory reform without first developing a clear vision for the business they’re trying to build. The structure should serve the strategy, not define it. Once they have clarity around their objectives, the next conversation should be with experienced legal ethics and regulatory counsel who understand both the opportunities and the limitations of the model. The most successful projects I’ve seen are the ones where business planning and regulatory planning happen together from the outset. ABSs and MSOs are generating a lot of excitement right now, but these models won’t make sense for many lawyers and law firms.


4. If you had to predict where the U.S. legal market looks in ten years, in terms of ownership structures, outside investment, and the role of non-lawyers in law firms, what does that look like to you?

Trisha: I think the next decade will be defined less by regulatory change and more by market change. The change is already here. Those trying to stop it haven’t caught up to that reality yet.

For years, the debate focused on whether regulators would permit greater participation by non-lawyers. Increasingly, I think the more important question is whether clients, technology, and market forces will demand it. We’re already seeing significant investment flowing into legal-adjacent businesses. We’re seeing technology fundamentally change how legal services are delivered. We’re seeing clients demand greater efficiency, transparency, and predictability. None of those trends are likely to reverse.

Ten years from now, I expect a much broader spectrum of legal service delivery models than we have today. Traditional partnerships will remain important, as will specialized boutiques. But we’ll also see more multidisciplinary businesses, more technology-enabled service providers, more strategic partnerships, and more capital entering the market.

What I don’t expect to change is the importance of professional values. The delivery mechanisms will evolve, but our ethical obligations, including our independence as a profession, should not.


5. What’s the biggest mistake you see people make when trying to structure an ABS or MSO deal, and how do they avoid it?

Trisha: Two mistakes, actually.

First, not consulting qualified and experienced counsel. Legal regulation differs from dental, accounting, or veterinary regulation. It’s important to have a legal team that has worked specifically in the field of ABSs, law firm M&A, or legal MSOs. That connects directly to the second mistake: treating ethics as a hurdle to clear rather than a framework for building the business. Legal teams that are at the table because they did a lot of deals in the dental space aren’t thinking about legal ethics and regulation the way this industry requires. That matters.

The most successful ABSs and MSO partnerships I’ve worked on start by asking how the structure can support professional independence, client protection, and long-term sustainability. The ones that struggle start with a financial objective and work backwards to ethics compliance. That approach consistently fails.

Conclusion

The ethics-first approach Trisha describes is a building strategy, not a compliance exercise. Whether the question is ABS or MSO, outside capital, or the role of non-lawyers in a firm, the advice is the same: start with what you are trying to build, get counsel who knows this specific area, and let the structure serve the strategy rather than define it.

*Disclaimer*

The content of this post is intended for general information only and should not be relied on as legal advice or interpreted as creating an attorney-client relationship. Although care has been taken to present accurate information, requirements and facts can change, and readers should confirm details with the Arizona Supreme Court or other applicable regulators before acting. The views expressed are solely my own and/or those of my quoted guests and do not reflect the positions of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court.

The Arizona ABS Committee met on May 12, 2026 and reviewed nine initial license applications, seven renewals, and five license updates.

The opinions expressed here are my own and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Once published, official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website.

INITIAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Nine companies sought initial ABS licenses this month. Five were approved, two deferred to a later month, one withdrew, and one received additional time to amend its application.

Forward Slash Health Law, LLC

Forward Slash Health Law seeks to support emerging physicians’ practices with legal aid for compliance and regulatory oversight. The Committee initially had concerns about the proposed compliance attorney, who the Committee had previously declined due to perceived lack of experience. After a close examination of the attorney’s ability to carry out the role within this company and for an additional ABS the attorney was set to take on compliance work for, the Committee approved 4-2. The two opposing members cited the company’s lack of Arizona presence in its objectives.

Wit Law, Inc.

Wit Law uses new technology to dispute erroneous parking tickets. The company had previously deferred its application after it came out that an outstanding disciplinary issue in another state was not disclosed in the original filing. Wit Law then requested to withdraw. This prompted a discussion about whether denial would be more appropriate, since a denial carries additional consequences for future applications. The Committee voted unanimously to approve the withdrawal.

Vanegas Law & Co, LLC

Vanegas Law & Co is an immigration law practice established in Florida. Questions came up around the company’s development plan, given the volume of work it already handles in Florida and its limited Arizona employee base. The Committee agreed Vanegas was meeting its requirement, but made clear that at renewal, the company will face a real burden to show it has been fulfilling this responsibility to benefit Arizona. Approved unanimously.

Legal Networks, LLC

Legal Networks intends to operate as a PI agency focused on Elder Abuse and Neglect cases. A background investigation turned up online complaints against the parent company. The attorneys set to lead operations addressed the Committee’s questions, explaining that the complaints arose from a Mass Tort covering over 100,000 clients, with a small number of complaints relative to that volume. The Committee also raised the fact that the company has no prior history in Elder Abuse and Neglect law. Approved unanimously.

Sambare, Qin & Gudise, LLC

This company intends to bring transparency to immigration applications through software that catches errors before submission. A few questions came up around company structure. Approved unanimously.

MBJ Legal, LLC

MBJ Legal is a legacy law office currently operating out of New York, with plans to relocate to Arizona to engage clients through its ABS. That structure drew scrutiny over whether the company would simply refer cases back to its New York offices. MBJ’s application was submitted before Arizona amended Rule 31.1 to require ABS entities to benefit Arizona. The Committee first worked through whether MBJ was required to meet the new requirement given the timing of its submission, then addressed what proving compliance would look like at renewal. The Committee voted unanimously to allow MBJ to amend its application to address these concerns.

DMX Partners, LLC

The Committee received new information from DMX Partners on the morning of the May meeting. Without enough time to review it, the application deferred to next month.

Newland Chase Legal, LLC

Newland Chase is a New York-based company with global reach focused on immigration solutions. The Committee noted the thoroughness of the application, pointing out that it had already addressed every concern the Committee might raise. Approved unanimously.

The Mesothelioma Center, LLC

With no company representative present, the application deferred to a future agenda.


RENEWAL LICENSE APPLICATIONS

Seven companies were up for renewal this month. Four were approved, two deferred, and one required no further action.

Cartiga Legal, LLC

Cartiga has had difficulty engaging Arizona clients and has worked mainly in Environmental Advocacy, pursuing recovery of environmental damage costs from responsible corporations rather than taxpayers. After a discussion about the company’s plans to fund an Arizona campaign, the renewal was approved.

Copper State Legal Services, LLC

Copper State has not yet launched its services in Arizona. Following a change in ownership, the new authorized persons laid out their plan for the company. The Committee approved the renewal unanimously.

Bad Drug Law Firm, PLLC

Operating in mass torts with over 300 active Arizona clients, the renewal was approved unanimously.

Meta-Attorney PC

The company requested a postponement until next month. Approved.

Reliant Law Group, PLLC

With no company representative present, the Committee deferred to next month.

McRae Management Services, LLC

McRae was placed on the agenda by mistake, having been approved in 2025. No further action was needed.

Swyft Legal, LLC (aka Smart Books, LLC)

Swyft had previously received a one-year renewal of its ABS license. Because the Supreme Court now allows two-year renewals, Swyft requested its application be updated to reflect current policy. The Committee approved the update.


LICENSEE UPDATES

Cartiga Legal, LLC

Cartiga sought approval for a compliance lawyer change alongside its renewal. Approved.

Aiken Farrell Kroloff, LLC

Aiken Farrell Kroloff requested a compliance lawyer change. A discussion preceded the vote, prompted by a last-minute email to Committee staff from a Committee member about this application. After speaking with the proposed compliance attorney, the Committee approved the request unanimously.

Bespoke Legal Services, PLLC

Bespoke requested a compliance lawyer change. Five members approved and two opposed, citing concerns about the proposed attorney’s experience and workload.

Vantage Law Firm, LLC

Having ceased all operations, Vantage Law Firm requested inactive status. Approved unanimously.

Skyview Legal Group, LLC

Requested to defer to next month’s agenda.


*Disclaimer*

The information in this post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Details may change. Verify information with the Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action. The opinions expressed are my own and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee or the Arizona Supreme Court. These are not the official meeting minutes. Official minutes are available on the Arizona Supreme Court’s website once published.

In February 2025, the Texas State Bar’s Professional Ethics Committee issued Opinion No. 706, the first ethics ruling to directly address Management Service Organizations (MSOs) in the legal field. Rather than simply answering a hypothetical question, Opinion 706 provides concrete guidance and signals that MSOs can be ethically integrated when they are structured correctly.


What Makes Opinion 706 Noteworthy

1. Permission by Omission

Until now, law firms considering MSO models were operating in a gray area. Opinion 706 does more than clarify the rules, it implicitly validates MSOs when they are designed with ethics in mind. That matters. It tells firms they do not need to fear the uncertainty. They can work with nonlawyer-owned entities if they respect the boundaries.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

2. Clear Rules on Fee Splitting

The Opinion draws a bright line. Nonlawyer entities cannot be paid a percentage of legal revenue. Rule 5.04(a) prohibits sharing fees with nonlawyers, and Opinion 706 reaffirms that prohibition. Even if the arrangement is framed as part of a broader technology or back-office service package, a fee tied to firm revenue is still not allowed.

This is consistent with past rulings. Office leases tied to firm income, bonus plans for nonlawyer staff based on profits, or auditors compensated on a percentage of fees have all been rejected as impermissible.

3. Equity in MSOs Is Allowed, With Limits

Opinion 706 also confirms that lawyers may invest in an MSO, even one that has nonlawyer owners, as long as the MSO is not engaged in practicing law. That means a law firm can hold equity in a services company. However, the Opinion cautions that lawyers cannot use equity stakes to do indirectly what the rules prohibit directly.

Conflicts of interest are a real concern. If the MSO’s services overlap with legal work, or if the firm recommends the MSO to clients, then Rules 1.06 and 1.08 come into play. In that case, disclosure and informed consent are required.


MSOs and ABS: Similar Goals, Different Structures

Both MSOs and Alternative Business Structures (ABS) were created to bring in nonlawyer resources, but they take very different forms.

Where They Overlap

Both models allow law firms to benefit from nonlawyer capital and expertise. Both are designed to let lawyers keep control of legal work and professional responsibility. And both respond to the same pressure: the need for innovation and growth in a profession that has traditionally been closed to outside ownership.

Where They Differ

The key differences between MSOs in Texas and ABS structures in Arizona come down to ownership, money, control, and compliance.

In Texas, an MSO can be owned by nonlawyers, but it exists separately from the law firm. The MSO provides business and administrative support while the law firm itself remains lawyer-owned. By contrast, Arizona’s ABS model allows nonlawyers to be admitted directly as partners in the firm, meaning ownership and management can be more fully integrated.

On the financial side, Texas draws a clear boundary. An MSO must be paid for services at fair market value. Payments cannot be tied to the law firm’s revenue or profits. Arizona’s ABS rules are more flexible. In that system, profit sharing with nonlawyer partners may be permitted, provided the arrangement complies with state regulations.

Control of legal work is another distinction. Under the MSO model, Texas makes clear that lawyers retain full and exclusive authority over legal judgment. ABS firms also preserve lawyer independence, but the governance structure can be more complicated, since nonlawyer owners may have a voice in management decisions.

Finally, the compliance burden is very different. MSOs, with the bright lines set out in Opinion 706, offer a more straightforward regulatory path. ABS firms, on the other hand, face a heavier lift. They require robust oversight and compliance systems to ensure nonlawyer involvement does not compromise professional obligations.

Why MSOs May Feel Safer Right Now

MSOs allow firms to outsource the heavy lifting of finance, HR, IT, or marketing while keeping the law practice itself separate. With Opinion 706, Texas has effectively said this can be done ethically, as long as the model is carefully structured. For many firms, especially those that want to grow or modernize without restructuring, the MSO offers a practical path.

Why ABS May Appeal to Bigger Visionaries

ABS structures open the door to direct outside investment and equity participation by nonlawyers. That can provide serious capital for expansion, technology development, or multidisciplinary services. The tradeoff is complexity. These models demand strong governance and, for some, raise sharper concerns about outside influence on legal work.


Why This Matters

MSOs offer flexibility without requiring a firm to change its DNA. ABS models promise greater transformation, but with greater risk. Texas has now provided a road map for the MSO route, and other states may watch closely to see how firms use it.

The views expressed in this comment are personal and do not represent the position of the Committee on Alternative Business Structures, the Arizona Supreme Court, or any organization with which the author is affiliated.

1 2