The 2025 NALFA Annual Conference: From Arizona-Centric to Nationwide Impact 

Reflections from the NALFA conference on where alternative business structures are heading next

I usually write here about what’s happening in the world of ABS firms, but for this post I want to start with a bit of personal news. I was recently appointed to the Arizona Committee on Alternative Business Structures (ABS). My first meeting is next week, and I’m genuinely excited to help evaluate applications, apply the governing rules, and support the continued, responsible growth of this program.

Because of that, it is important to keep in mind that everything written here reflects my own personal views and not those of the Arizona ABS Committee, the Arizona Supreme Court, or any other entity. Nothing in this post should be taken as legal advice.

With that out of the way, let’s talk about last week’s National ABS Law Firm Association (NALFA) annual conference in Scottsdale, AZ. It highlighted just how far the ABS model has come in a short time. Attendance nearly doubled from last year, and the tone felt different: less about defending the concept and more about shaping what comes next. Judges, regulators, managing partners, and compliance leaders all brought strong perspectives on where the model should go and where it should not.

Setting the Stage: The Expanding ABS Landscape

The conference opened with a comprehensive update from Don Bivens, NALFA’s president, joined by Anu Seethee, Chief Legal Officer at LegalZoom, Chase Hertelfrom A2J Ventures, and Nic Edgson from Big Auto Law Group. They painted a clear picture of momentum, even in the face of resistance.

The discussion focused on new jurisdictions exploring, expanding, and adopting ABS-style reforms, including Washington, D.C., Puerto Rico, Tennessee, and Texas, with ABS platforms also taking shape in Washington State and elsewhere. They also described ongoing efforts to counter the California backlash, where opposition has been loud but not necessarily representative of the broader trend toward innovation.

LegalZoom’s perspective was particularly interesting. As one of the first national brands to partner with ABS firms, Seethee emphasized the company’s commitment to responsible growth and collaboration with regulators to expand access to affordable legal services. Her remarks underscored what many in the room already felt: the future of ABS is not limited to one state or one model.

Chief Justice Ann Timmer: Keeping It Close to Home

Chief Justice Ann Timmer followed with a clear message that she believes Arizona’s ABS framework should stay focused on Arizona. She emphasized the state’s leadership in opening the door for non-lawyer ownership and urged ABS firms to direct their innovation efforts locally. It was a reminder of the judiciary’s cautious optimism, proud of the reform but wary of its expansion beyond state borders. Her call for firms to include a “public service commitment” in applications underscored that tension between regulatory control and market reality.

David Rizzo: The National View from KPMG

If Timmer represents the cautious camp, David Rizzo represents the opposite. As Compliance Lawyer and Managing Partner of KPMG’s ABS firm, Rizzo described a model built for national impact. His firm operates across jurisdictions, using Arizona’s structure as a launchpad rather than a fence line. His remarks sparked one of the clearest divides of the conference: should ABS be a state-bound regulatory sandbox or a foundation for a new national legal services economy? 

I had the pleasure of sitting next to Mr. Rizzo during the event and to discuss the long-term goals of ABS firms. We shared the view that if innovation and access to justice are among the central purposes of Arizona’s ABS framework, then it is worth recognizing that impactful ABS firms may naturally extend beyond Arizona’s borders. When a firm develops technology that lowers costs, improves service delivery, or expands access to legal help, regardless of geography, it is fulfilling the public policy intent behind the program.

This perspective seemed to conflict with some of the other speakers, particularly those who emphasized keeping ABS work within Arizona’s borders. Yet the experience of Utah’s failed sandbox offers a cautionary example. Utah’s program is ultimately collapsing in large part because of its “nexus requirement,” which limited participation to entities with a primarily Utah connection. That restriction stifled growth and innovation. It is difficult to promote meaningful reform if the framework is designed to remain insular.

Lynda Shely: The Compliance Lawyer as Firm Leader

Ethics authority Lynda Shely focused on the operational side of compliance, calling it the “backbone” of legitimacy for every ABS firm. She reminded attendees that compliance lawyers are personally responsible for ensuring every rule is followed: “it’s your license on the line.” She also argued that the compliance lawyer should serve as the firm’s managing partner, ensuring that ethical oversight and leadership stay aligned.

While Shely’s commitment to integrity and professionalism is unquestionable, her position on governance drew some discussion. One of the key innovations of the ABS framework is that it allows firms to bring in experts from other disciplines (such as operations, finance, technology, or marketing) and offer them equity. Requiring the managing partner to also be the compliance lawyer risks undercutting that flexibility.

For example, if an exceptional immigration attorney leads a firm that becomes an ABS to expand access through technology or outside investment, it seems counterintuitive to require that person to also serve as a compliance specialist. The better approach may be to empower compliance lawyers as independent officers within the firm, with the authority and oversight necessary to ensure adherence to ethical standards, while allowing management and innovation to flourish in tandem. That balance would seem to better reflect the spirit of the ABS framework: multidisciplinary collaboration built on accountability and trust. Whether Arizona ultimately embraces that flexibility remains to be seen

The MSO Model: New Infrastructure for ABS Growth

Andy Kvesic, Josh Porte and Seth Deutsch introduced what might be the next frontier, the management services organization (MSO) model as a companion to ABS firms. The idea is to separate business infrastructure from legal practice to maintain compliance while scaling operations efficiently. They discussed variations on cost-plus structures and “harvest events” that make this model financially viable even in complex practices like mass tort.

Their remarks, echoed by Fredric Litwiniuk at Litco Law, positioned MSOs as the logical evolution (or possibly alternative, depending on the goals of the firm) of the ABS framework, a structure that enables collaboration with non-lawyer investors while preserving professional independence.

The Utah Lesson: Why the Sandbox Failed

One of the more sobering panels came from Natalie Anne Knowlton and Stanford Law School’s Rhode Center on the Legal Profession, where they discussed many topics but in perhaps most interestingly – unpacking why Utah’s regulatory sandbox faltered. It seems to be one of the biggest culprits was the Utah nexus requirement, which effectively limited participation to entities with a Utah-focused connection. Innovation cannot thrive when tied to geography, they argued, a message that landed pointedly given Arizona’s own internal debate.

Key Takeaways and Next Steps

A few threads ran through every hallway conversation:

  • Arizona is still the center of gravity, but the gravitational pull is weakening as firms look outward.
  • Compliance is professionalized, not optional, and it is evolving into a leadership role.
  • The MSO model could define the next phase of growth, providing scalable infrastructure for ABS firms.
  • Regulatory advocacy is heating up beyond Arizona. With Georgia’s favorable rules and the ABA’s Center for Innovation gaining attention, momentum is spreading.

The conference wrapped with a reminder from Judge Foster about the Arizona Judicial Council’s rule review process. The next major update comes in December, after a 30-day public comment window. It is another signal that the framework is still in motion and that those shaping it have a voice.

*Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this post are entirely my own and do not represent the views of the Arizona Committee on Alternative Business Structures, the Arizona Supreme Court, or any other entity. The information in this post is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney–client relationship. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, details may change, and readers should verify information with the official Arizona Supreme Court or relevant regulatory authorities before taking action.

National ABS Law Firm Association Logo

Related Posts

Leave a Reply